I dont know which will be better and their about the same price. Their the yellow top optima and the odyssey pc1200. Their both great batteries but Im not sure. I like the small size of the odyssey (incase I want to relocate later). The terminals on the odyssey are in the right locations but I dont know if my alternator will do fine with this application. Any of you have the odyssey? Is their any drawbacks from having this battery?