Looking down on people driving RHD Supras vs having a justified preference of which you'd like to buy are definitely two different things and I hope you aren't categorizing me into the elitist crowd. Shoot, I did a photo session with a RHD car last month lol. Having an Mk5 also, those get bullied by mk3/4 owners more than the LHD RHD situation. I noticed the mk3 owners go the hardest
Agreed - there's a huge difference between having a preference and talking trash/being an asshole/etc. I figured that was self evident from what I was saying, apologies if my sleep-deprived rant wasn't clear.
I prefer LHD myself just because of my driving 'muscle memory'. If I ever have an RHD car for some time and get used to it, I might change my mind. But that's in no way the sort of thing I'm talking about.
If you bought a LHD Supra and enjoy it, that's great!
It's the folks that bought a LHD Supra and spend their time on social media talking smack about RHD's, or laugh reacting to anyone selling one for more than $20k, etc - that's the problem.
As to the MK5, that's a really complicated one. Like many other OG Supra owners, the whole car feels like Toyota deliberately did it as a dismissive, hateful betrayal of our loyalty and pride in Toyota's golden era work. Having worked on a fair number of N54/N55/B58 BMW's, I have a pretty passionate dislike for them that is well founded in how failure prone, overpriced, and overcomplicated they are. It's every bit the very opposite of what it's like to work on a Toyota.
Where Toyota cares about the details and robust designs to the very small details, BMW seems to take the exact opposite approach, and carefully designs components to be as cheap and as weak and as failure prone as possible whilst still making it to the end of warranty coverage.
Now, Toyota did put some effort into going through BMW's parts bin and culling out a lot of those problematic parts and cheap shit versions of things before they slapped a Supra badge on it. So saying it's purely a BMW product isn't 100% accurate. It's all BMW parts, built on a BMW leased Magna-Steyr production line in Austria, but Toyota's team threw out a lot of the major problematic pieces before they could end up on a Supra. So that's good. It's best described, IMHO, as a Toyota-curated BMW product.
That doesn't save them from all the BMW issues, though, especially in regards to the DME and body electronics, and there was that really bad batch of engines in that range of '21 models. I know personally of three lemon law buybacks of '21 model Supras specifically from that issue alone. In all three cases, a Toyota dealership replaced the engine, and they could never get the DME or electronics to act right ever again. One particularly egregious case had the owner getting dragged along for ~6 months going back and forth with various DME reflashes and changes trying to fix his car.
So there's a real grey area on dealership support, parts support, and past-warranty support for the MK5's and I can't help but suspect that MK5's will start dying quickly as repair costs become instantly prohibitive when they're 5-7 years old and outside of warranty coverage, much like other BMW products.
So ultimately, I'm astonished and frankly pissed off that Toyota was so short sighted to think that a BMW could replace a Supra - if it could have, everyone would have sold their MK4's for those BMW's ages ago.
But then I put myself in the shoes of a guy that wants to buy a new sports car in 2020-2022ish, etc, and look out at what's available. The Zupra is a real contender in that regard because everything else is kind of long in tooth and ho-hum. Especially now that '23 models are shipping with a 6MT (finally!)
I don't hate someone for buying a MK5, but it's hard to have a positive reaction to those cars because of how Toyota did the OG Supra community in making it. Toyota execs courted quite a few of OG Supra elite, including our own
@KenHenderson and all of the messaging from our crew was loud and clear - Toyota product, Toyota engine, 6MT trans, tuning support. I6 would be great but not required. 6MT trans. Tuning support. Over and over again. Lots of back and forth happened discussing GR series V6's and UR series V8's as a basis for a new Supra engine. Personally, I'm willing to bet the V35A twin turbo V6 found in the new Tundras initially started life as a blueprint for the new Supra engine.
But ultimately ALL of that was completely and utterly ignored. So either those Toyota execs were courting us in bad faith, having already made the decision for a BMW product but hoping to do a 'temperature check' against us gaijin enthusiasts for it, or they vindictively did the OPPOSITE of what we wanted for.... whatever reason.
The fact that Toyota has ~200+ Billion in development capital means every cheerleader saying that developing an all-Toyota MK5 wasn't possible or was too expensive is 100% delusional and bullshitting themselves.
If Toyota simply wanted to dismissively and cheaply get the 'Supra monkey' off their backs, and wanted to do it in the cheapest possible way that required the least effort or care or pride on their part... what would they have done different? IMHO, Nothing.
So I'm betting it wasn't a matter of deliberate hatred for old MK4 guys or older Supra owners - it was a matter of being lazy cheapasses with no pride that simply wanted the world to STFU about the Supra. They saw the timing against the current market was ideal because there was minimal competition in the sports car arena, so even a lukewarm half-ass badge-engineered attempt would be cheered on by the press, plus they got a SWEET deal with BMW on other tech-sharing that probably put them in the black for the whole thing overall. Win-win-win by corporate bean counter upper management standards that dictate their colorless, soulless, and pointless lives.
Any way you cut the cake, it's a loaf of shit to older Supra guys, so it's hard to separate the emotional reaction from the MK5's genesis and development from seeing one on the street. That, unfortunately, carries over to the owners of MK5's.
I don't hate anyone for buying a new sports car and trying to have some fun with their hard earned money.
I don't hate the fact that a profitable and successful MK5 does wonders for enhancing the chances of a proper MK6.
I don't even hate the MK5 itself as a car. Yes, it took me a long time to separate my feelings about how Toyota did us as a community, and how I felt about the car itself. It is a cool car and a welcome addition to the market right now. It just doesn't deserve its badging, is all.
But I sure as hell hate that car's proverbial 'parents', and how it came to exist.
Edit - typo fixes